Josh's Story

My Entire Life
  I've been featured!
Categories Not ...

Featured Story

Taking the Heat in the Kitchen

Len Vertefeuille was born and raised into a loving family on the East coast. He now lives in North Carolina and he and his wife Lisa have two children who mean the world to Len. He has been working in the Warren Wilson College kitchen since 1989. Len enjoys cooking for and working alongside ...


All Alone at the Sixty-Four World's ...

The backstage of the pavilion was simple with its wooden floors and temporary props. The 1964 World’s Fair of Flushing, NY would come and go and no one would remember the little five year-old girl who played with her Barbies in its grand shadow. While some country stars were just cutting ...


Browse for more stories

Josh's Story > Categories > I've been featured!

Success is the Best Revenge 

Written by Storyteller: Tamar Burris   Comments: 6


Josh Opperman thought had met “the one.” Having courted his girl for several years, he was ready to take the plunge. Loaded with ammo from several discussions about the shape, sparkle, and setting of the bauble she’d like to wear for the rest of her life, Josh headed out to the jewelry store where he spotted the exact ring he’d been looking for. It was over two carats of flawless diamond set in platinum. So what that it would cost his life savings? Josh put money aside from every paycheck to cover the ring. His soon-to-be fiancé was the perfect woman, all that money for the perfect ring for her was worth it … or so Josh thought.


It seems there’s always stress when planning a wedding, but things between Josh and his fiancé weren’t going as well as they should have after the proposal. A few months into the engagement and they were fighting more often than not. Although they lived in the same apartment, they started spending less and less time together. They were like two ships passing in the night and Josh could feel the distance between the two of them growing wider and wider. Even so, he wasn’t entirely prepared for what came next. She wore that beautiful token of his love on her finger after all.


Josh had spent the weekend away at his best friend’s bachelor party. Coming home, he was looking forward to seeing his fiancé. However, when he opened the door he was met with a half-empty apartment and a sparkling diamond ring lying on the table. That was it. She was gone. Josh’s future had fallen apart. Devastated, he wanted to take that ring and throw it, just break it into the millions of tiny pieces that his heart had become. But, he knew that diamonds are essentially unbreakable. Through the haze of shock, he also remembered how much money the ring had cost him. How he’d carefully scrimped and saved to purchase it. Instead of throwing the ring or stomping on it, he eventually decided to return it.


Walking into the jewelry store where he’d bought the engagement ring, Josh knew he’d never recoup the entire amount he’d thrown down on the pricey trinket. But he felt confident he’d get a decent price and be able to move on from the experience, do something nice for himself with that extra cash. To his shock, the jeweler offered him only 32% of what he’d spent! Less than half? It wasn’t even really “used”. Josh couldn’t believe it. He stormed out of the store, now nursing indignation along with his broken heart.


Looking at the flash of the ring only brought Josh pain. It was a horrible reminder of a love lost. But, unless he wanted to suck it up and take a huge financial loss, he was stuck with it. So, he took the ring and hid it in a closed drawer where he wouldn’t have to look at it all the time. After that, he went about his business, licking his wounds and getting over the failed romance. He went to work. He went out with friends. He tried not to think t about the ring. But, try as you might, the mental wheels kept turning. Talking with his sister, Mara, the two stumbled upon an idea. What if there was a way to get rid of the ring at a decent price and give Josh some closure at the same time?

“Looking at … the ring only brought Josh pain. It was a horrible reminder of a love lost. But, unless he wanted to suck it up and take a huge financial loss, he was stuck with it.”



After extensive research, Josh had come to find that what had happened to him was common practice—the jewelry industry typically offers only about a quarter or so of a ring’s original value when people look to return jewelry. It leaves a lot of people in the lurch, people just like Josh. In fact, with more than 1 million divorces each year there stood to be billions of diamonds going unsold or sold for undervalued prices every year. Seeing a void in the market and the possibility for a new business opportunity, Josh and Mara decided to create an online auction house, a place where jilted lovers (or anyone really!) could buy and sell jewelry safely at decent prices for both parties. Teaming up with a GIA graduated gemologist in New York City’s diamond district to ensure authenticity and safety, Josh took his online auction site live in January 2007. Among the first items on “I Do Now I Don’t” ( was Josh’s ring, of course.


Josh eventually sold his ring for 70% of its original cost. Not only did he recoup most of his investment, the sale also allowed him to move on from the pain of being dumped. And, it opened up a whole new line of work. Pretty soon after the launch, Josh quit his job—there was just too much work to be done! In one year’s time, the inventory on “I Do Now I Don’t” had increased from four rings (including Josh’s) to nearly 600. In addition to rings, they also began auctioning necklaces, bracelets, watches, and the like and they’ve recently expanded to add wedding dresses. Now operated by Josh, Mara, and a handful of employees, the auction house takes a small percentage when a piece of jewelry is sold, in exchange for acting as a clearinghouse in the sale. When an auction ends, the money is sent to their business and held there while the in-house gemologist checks the ring for authentication before making the switch.


Operating a sales site for jilted lovers may sound depressing but it’s brought nothing but joy to Josh and the others who use the site. With each item, a seller gets to vent and tell their story. They get a forum where they are heard and then when an auction ends their wallets are reimbursed. For Josh, selling his ring to a happy couple and giving it a new life brought him all the closure he needed. Now, others are experiencing that closure and it is Josh who can help them. At the end of the day, Josh feels good about the people he’s helped on both sides of a sale. As for his former fiancé? Well, he doesn’t know exactly what she’s doing or if she knows of the web site but in retrospect he’s grateful that the engagement fiasco happened. If it hadn’t, he wouldn’t have stumbled upon this wonderful business venture!


About a year after founding I Do Now I Don’t Josh found his true soul mate. Having married her after a happy and successful engagement, he feels that he finally knows what love is. And, with the sale of each ring or wedding dress, he’s hoping he helps others move on to find their true love as well.

Thank you Josh, for sharing your Story with us.


Our Stories and pictures are the sole copyright of their Authors and may not be reprinted or used without their permission.
© 2009 by Tamar Burris and Story of My Life®

Email this Story

Read more of Josh's Stories  | Read other great Stories


You must be registered to leave comments. Register here! It's free!

Already a member? Login here

Member Since
Apr 2008
Chuck Stallong said:
posted on Jul 02, 2009

They only give you back 25% of the value? The ring is "used" what does that mean - it could possibly have some scratches or dents? I don't get it- the value of the diamond is the same. What a rip off. Yet another reason why I'm never getting married.

Member Since
Aug 2007
Kristen Kuhns said:
posted on Jul 02, 2009

I am digging that  1.75carat Fancy Intense Yellow SI1 Square Radiant Diamond (R1745) " :)

Member Since
Apr 2009
Jocelyn Bushell said:
posted on Jul 02, 2009

I am not going to return the ring of my first marriage; i had it made into a lovely necklace instead. You could have gotten cuff links, but I like your solution (start a new company for this!) better. The whole jewelry industry seems like such a bunch of scammers as it is anyway. I've heard there are plenty of diamonds out there but they buy them up to keep the market artificially high.

Member Since
Aug 2007
Agnes Williams said:
posted on Jul 03, 2009

Back in the day, a lady always gave back the ring no matter what, but these days I hear of people keeping their rings (engagements, not marriages Jocelyn) :). We never knew back then how much they really cost. It wasn't until much later that I learned just HOW expensive engagement rings really were. Personally I'd rather have a nice vacation than a huge ring on my finger. 

Member Since
Aug 2007
Gina Pertonelli said:
posted on Jul 06, 2009

and good to know (about the resell value etc).

Member Since
Jul 2009
Jenny Highland said:
posted on Jul 14, 2009

I'm new to this site, but it seems odd to me that people get comments and questions and they do not respond. Is this normal behavior for people who are in this featured section to not respond to people who show interest in their stories?